All-on-4 vs Traditional Dentures: Pros and Cons

Comparing All-on-4 to traditional dentures? Our Rochelle Park implant dentists, Dr. Schepis & Dr. Maher, break down the pros and cons of each full arch restoration. read time: 5 Minute Read

Choosing Your Path to a Full Smile

Losing a full arch of teeth, or facing the reality of needing them all replaced, is a significant life event. The decision you make next will impact your health, confidence, and daily quality of life for years to come. The two most common solutions presented to patients are traditional removable dentures and the modern All-on-4 dental implant technique. While both replace a full set of teeth, they are fundamentally different in almost every way. At Perfected Smiles in Rochelle Park, NJ, Dr. Jason Schepis and Dr. Ryan Maher believe in empowering patients with clear, comprehensive information. This guide will objectively compare the pros and cons of these two full arch restoration options.

The Reality of Traditional Removable Dentures

Traditional dentures are the classic, non-surgical option. Their primary "pro" is a lower initial cost and a faster fabrication process. However, the list of cons is extensive and impacts daily life. Dentures are removable and rest directly on the gum tissue, relying on suction (and often messy, unreliable denture adhesives) to stay in place. This lack of stability is the source of most patient complaints. It can cause embarrassing slippage when talking or laughing, and it severely limits chewing power, forcing many patients to avoid nutritious foods like fresh vegetables, nuts, or firm meats. The most significant, hidden drawback is jawbone loss. Without tooth roots or implants to stimulate it, the jawbone begins to shrink (a process called atrophy). This is why dentures become loose over time, require frequent, costly relines, and lead to a sunken, prematurely aged facial appearance.

The All-on-4 Difference: A Permanent, Fixed Solution

The All-on-4 dental implant technique is a complete paradigm shift. Instead of a removable appliance, this advanced procedure uses four strategically placed titanium implants to permanently anchor a full, custom bridge of new teeth directly to your jaw. These dental implants act just like natural tooth roots. This design immediately solves all the major problems associated with dentures. There is absolutely no slipping, no clicking, and zero need for adhesives. The bridge is fixed in place and only removed by your dentist for professional cleanings. Because it is anchored to the implants, your chewing power is restored to near-natural levels, allowing you to eat all the foods you love with complete confidence. Furthermore, the All-on-4 bridge is "palateless," meaning it does not cover the roof of your mouth, which allows for a more natural feel and a full appreciation for the taste of food.

A Side-by-Side Comparison: Lifestyle and Long-Term Health

When you compare them directly, the choice becomes clear. Dentures are a removable prosthetic that must be taken out daily, can cause sore spots, limit your diet, and allow your jawbone to deteriorate. All-on-4 is a permanent, fixed part of your body that you brush just like natural teeth, allows you to eat anything, and actively stops jawbone loss. The dental implants fuse with your bone (a process called osseointegration), providing the vital stimulation needed to keep your jaw healthy and maintain your facial structure. While the initial All-on-4 cost is higher, it is a one-time investment in a permanent solution, versus the repeated lifetime costs of denture relines, adhesives, and replacements. As expert implant dentists in Rochelle Park, Dr. Schepis and Dr. Maher prioritize this long-term health and lifestyle benefit for their patients.

Make an Informed Decision About Your Smile

Choosing between dentures and All-on-4 dental implants is a decision about your future quality of life. Our team at Perfected Smiles is here to provide the expert guidance you need. To learn more about the All-on-4 procedure, its benefits, and to see if you are a candidate, we invite you to contact our Rochelle Park, NJ office today to schedule your consultation with Dr. Jason Schepis or Dr. Ryan Maher.

Book now your consultation!

Book Your Consultation